A Pane in the Glass Podcast
This podcast is hosted by Bill Tschirhart, a chartered professional coach with Coaches of Canada. It's for coaches, instructors , athletes & parents at all levels of experience & skills. Using articles from Bill's coaching manual ("A Pane in the Glass: A Coach's Companion"), his blog site (truenorthbill.blogspot.com), his 30+ years coaching & instructing athletes, augmented by interviews with highly skilled & experienced experts, the aim of "A Pane In The Glass Podcast" to provide a valuable resource of information all the while producing episodes that will entertain the listener.
A Pane in the Glass Podcast
Notes From My Clipboard
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of "A Pane In The Glass Podcast" I share notes I took as I watched the first Grand Slam of Curling for this season. In one of the sections on my clipboard, I made notes about the "bunny hop" that many of the female teams have incorporated into their bushing system. Rather than my analysis of this brushing modality I referred to a previous episode of the podcast. In that episode I shared the microphone with Dr. Glenn Paulley who has forgotten more about brushing than most of us will ever know. Below these show notes is a link to that episode. I end with a sound bite from Joanne Courtney who expertly shared her thoughts on the two gold medal games.
https://apaneintheglasspodcast.buzzsprout.com/1922969/episodes/18883285
You are just moments away from another episode of a Payment Glass Podcast. This is your host, Bill Sheerhart, chartered professional coach with coaches of Canada once again. The episode this week is centered on the first Grand Slam of Curling event for the season. It's taking place as I compile this episode in Save on Foods Armina in downtown Victoria, British Columbia, supernatural British Columbia. The best teams in the world are there, and some new teams that are trying to be in that group. It has been an interesting round robin. I am publishing this before the actual end of the competition, and I have been making notes on what I have seen on my television screen throughout the week. So again, thank you for joining me. So let's have a look at the first grand plan of curling event for 2026-27. The first item up on my clipboard as I watch the games is timing. Now I'm not referring to the timing system that's used to time the duration of the game, thinking time, uh timeout, and that sort of thing, although I will throw in a comment or two about that. I'm referring to timing rocks as they make their way down the ice. It does seem as though hog-to-hog timing is the favorite method of timing the rocks. It seems to be easily understood by spectators. Commentators uh tend to like it, and I have nothing really too much to say against it. I'm looking at it through the eyes of a curler. And any time that I talk about split or interval timing, I prefer the term interval timing, I'm referring to the amount of time that a rock takes from back line to near hog line, or sometimes T-line to near hog line. As a front-end player all my career, it certainly helped me judge the velocity of the rock. It was never the sole decider on whether I should just clean or brush vigorously or just brush uh casually or whatever it might be. But it was very useful because it was information provided to me during the actual journey of the rock. Uh if if you think about hog-to-hog timing, well, the shot's pretty much over. And I don't really see too many of the players' skips like it because they can see the hog lines, and so they will click their watch as it crosses the uh closer hogline to the person delivering the rock to the near, nearer hog line, so it makes sense for them, but you don't see too many of the players clicking their watch from hog line to hog line. There's too much else that's going to draw their attention. My point here is this. As I watch rocks being delivered and the brushers are in frame, a lot of times you'll see a stopwatch in the brusher's hand, and it clicks either at the back line or the T line and then at the hog line, and then it uh goes into the pocket, or it may be tethered to the athlete's waist. It's being used a lot. So those people out there who think that, well, players would rather just judge the rock. Well, you always want to judge the rock. No question about it. But interval timing is a great tool. I've used it literally forever in my career, and I think I I always will feel very uh passionate about it. That's how I feel about interval timing. Oh, yes, I did say that I would uh mention about my thoughts about the timing of the game. I thought it was very interesting that the thinking time had been reduced from 30 minutes, I think, to 29. So they reduced it by a minute, but they added a half a minute to timeouts instead of 60 uh seconds, it's now 90 seconds, so it seems to be a bit of a trade-off there. So uh not so consequential, I think. Uh and I like the pace of play. That's one of the things I enjoy about uh this land, the fact that they're using eight ends, and I'll have more to say about that a little bit later as well. I don't recall the actual game this week. Uh it was it was very early on. I think they were referring to uh Kevin Coey, and I heard the phrase don't be predictable. Wow, I jump off my coach and hurrah, hurrah. I could not agree more. Don't be predictable. I find that when curling teams play in the same competitive environment and stick to systems that do seem to work, but they get to know the systems that are going to be used by their opponents and future opponents, and so they plan uh accordingly. But then you come up with a team that decides that, you know, we're gonna try to achieve the same objective with this shot, but we're not we are not going to play it the way they think we're going to play it. Or it might be more a macro decision. Conventional wisdom might dictate that this end, you know, end score last rocket vantage gets played a certain way. Well, again, we'll we we're not going to jump off uh high buildings and keep away sharp objects here. We're not gonna be off the wall, but we're not going to allow our opponent ever to assume that we're going to do something a certain way. And just that doubt in their mind, the fact that they have to spend mental preparation time and resources trying to figure out what we're gonna do. We've already taken them out of their predictable way of playing. So, again, whichever one of the commentators that said that, I wish I could remember who it was, I would strongly uh say to every team out there, don't be predictable. There are a number of teams in the competition. I don't have a hard and fast number, but when I saw Team Hardy play uh one of its early games, I took notice of the fact that uh even though it's Team Hardy, who of course played with Bruce Malick and is now uh delivering the third rocks on the team, Ross White, who was a skip, a very good skip, is delivering the last two rocks in the fourth position. We have the sport science to suggest that for a variety of reasons, I'm not gonna delve into it in detail right now, but we do have the sport science that would suggest that a person who is moving up and down the ice, brushing rocks, seeing shots from both angles, from both the delivery end and the playing end, is actually in a better position to play the last two shots of the end. The sports science is out there for that. Now, I'm not suggesting that every team do what Team Hardy is doing, and there are others in that situation as well. But when a team is newly formed and you're trying to decide on the division of labor, don't discount the possibility that the skip, the person whose name is assigned to the team, should deliver the last two rocks. Perhaps it's someone else on the team who would be better suited to deliver the last two rocks of the end. And as I said, this we have the smart science to suggest that it is a viable way of deciding the positions, especially on the back end. So, team Harney, good for you. And perhaps your team needs to have that discussion. Blank ends. The rule on the slam is that a team that blanks an end is allowed to do so, but you can only do it one time. If you blank an end after you've done it once, the hammer goes to the opposition. I think that's a great rule. I have felt that way for a long, long time, especially in 10 end games where a team blanks one, two, three ends in a row, and it really does shut down the offensive capabilities of their opponent. And so often, and interestingly enough, I remember this statistic that when a team blanks an end, and I'm not sure if this statistic holds still today, if Jerry Gertz is listening, he'll certainly tell me if I'm uh correct or not, that if you blank the end, you actually only have a 25% chance of scoring a multiple end. You only have a 50-50 uh percent uh chance of scoring at all. And a lot of times when events are over, uh and I will use the first half of the games when ends are blanked for that purpose, and anytime I did that, sure enough, it was about 25%. So I say to all teams, when you're considering blanking an end, you might want to let that number cross your mind. Is it really worth it? Now, in the second half of the game, game management, when you are seeing uh the uh last couple ends and who's gonna have last rock. And I'll talk about the shootout a little bit later here on my coach's clipboard. Full marks to the to the uh the slam with this rule of you you get one chance to blank an end without the other team uh getting last rock as a result. Well, there's my feelings about blank end. Well, Bill, why wait? Let's let's talk about the shootout. Again, I have felt for quite some time, and I feel the same way about my summer sport of lawn bowling, that when you sign on to play whether it's eight ends or tens, that's the duration of the game. And if the score is tied at the end of regulation play, both teams should have the same opportunity or an equal opportunity to win the game. And if you stop and think about it, it doesn't really change the strategy, the end of game strategy, as much as you might think. Because a team that is in a deficit position uh has to decide, especially if they do have last rock in the penultimate end or the last end of the game, do we try to win it in regulation, if I can use that term, or are we quite happy to go to the shootout? I'm a big fan of this. And of course, from uh an organization perspective, if you're a bond spiel or competition play-down organizer, you're not gonna have to put up with a fully played last end. The shootout is quick, it's short, and it's meaningful because you know drawing to the button is what the game is all about. But here's what I don't understand. Somebody can help me with this. Right now, if both players involved in the shootout for their team cover the pin, then it's a a redraw, but this time there's no brushing. Well, okay. But we do have the technology, if both cover the pin, to find out who really did come closest to covering the pin and the part of the rock that is in question here is not the edge of the rock, but if if we're talking about covering the pin, it's who has covered the pin better by the center of the rock. And it it's just simply called the triangulation method. There are holes drilled at the edge of the forefoot, and when you're using a laser measure, it's very simple to find out who actually was closer to the pin. So shoot out, love it, exciting, quick. Hippity hoppity, here comes Peter Cottontail. Well, what's this all about? Well, the bunny hop is alive and well. We've seen it a number of times, or at least I've seen it a number of times this week. And if you've been watching The Slam from Supernatural British Columbia, Victoria, you will have seen The Bunny Hop. Now, I'm going to refer you to another episode of the podcast, and it was with my friend Dr. Glenn Polly, who has his own podcast now. And when I get a chance to talk to Glenn, I want him to come on my podcast to promote his podcast because he's forgotten more about the science of delivering rocks and brushing than I think I will ever know. But he talked about the bunny hop in an episode, season five, episode six. Season five, episode six. It was on my birthday, March 21st of this past year. And he talks about a number of aspects about brushing, but particularly about the bunny hop. So I'm not going to say anything about the bunny hop. I would rather that you go to that episode again. It's in this season, season five, episode six. It was a number of months ago, March 21st. Dr. Glenn and Bill talk about brushing. And you'll understand somebody who has done some research on it, and you'll fill us all in on whether it's a good idea or not. The bunny hop. So often I will see a rock being brushed, and the thought, and sometimes I actually verbalize it, and what I will I say to myself is if they had just watched the shot as opposed to brushing the shot, it would have ended up in exactly the same place. If they had just watched it, so how effective was the brushing? Anytime teams come to me and ask about brushing and the current science and what system they should adopt, I always start by saying, tell me why you think a rock curls. No, you you may be wrong, you may be correct, but that will tell you how to brush rocks. We're brushing rocks for basically one of three reasons. The most obvious reason is to help maintain the rock's velocity so that it extends its journey down the ice. That's the basics, right? The other reason is about the amount of curl, especially in terms of a takeout. The conventional wisdom for so long was we brush the rock if the person was a little bit inside, narrow of the brush, or it's it's curling more than anticipated, so we want to reduce the amount of curl. And so we brush the rock for that reason. But you can actually, on a takeout, increase the amount of curl. Now, again, I'm not gonna go into the details about that, it's very personal with me, but it's based on discussions with with people who uh have done more of the actual research, but certainly my participant observation. And my point again is this, and this is what I see. I will see a front end brushing a rock uh to reduce the amount of curl, and then they're brushing the rock on a draw to try to increase the amount of curl. And they're using exactly the same system to do that. Now, I'm not talking about the orientation of the brush, whether it's in the knifing position or the standard uh uh uh uh perpendicular to the path of the rock. I'm not referring to that, but I I I still see brushing out there, and I I'm I'm kind of scratching my head. Why are you brushing the rock like that? I don't understand. I wish I could have a uh conversation with those brushers in the team and the coach. Tell me why you're doing that. I'm interested, and you might change my mind, but well, again, had they just watched the rock, it would have stopped in exactly the same place. And then we come to my favorite word. I hope that with the change in commentators, I would no longer hear the word carve. It's a most inappropriate term because it implies scratching the ice. Because anytime something is carved or cutting, well, the yellow stuff polishes the ice. It does not do anything in terms of cutting or scraping or scratching. I really wish they would stop using the term carved because it just is inappropriate. One more comment up not about brushing, but about the brushes. I see a lot of curlers using a brush as a stabilizer. In other words, they have the brush, the entire brush, on the ice, obviously with the uh yellow end turned up, and a hand on the handle, somewhat close to the head, so the fingers can go underneath, but they use it as a stabilizer. And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. So uh don't ever let someone tell you that if you're going to use your brush as a sliding device, that it needs to be in the traditional position, you know, hand two thirds of the way down, handle across the hip, and head of the brush opposite the stone. And and that's all great. That's that's perfectly fine. But it's not the only way to hold the brush that's going to. Be the implement that you're going to use as a slide of the bike. Putting it on the ice in the manner that I described a minute or so ago, it's just as good. Now let's talk a little about actually delivering the curling rocks. Now remember everybody who is watching the games on television, they are playing on championship ice with rocks that have been textured and probably textured a second time, although I haven't seen all the games this week. Uh and perhaps the H technicians have re-textured part way through the week, I'm not sure. So you're seeing the games being played on ice that is not the same as at your curling facility, for sure. But I hope that you have been impressed with two aspects of the delivery of the rocks. On draws, have you counted the number of rotations? Seven, eight. I saw one at nine. Nine rotations. Now that was a little excessive, possibly. But there's lots of rotation. Now, it is because they're playing on championship bikes, no question about it. But that does translate to your delivery of the rock at your curling facility. I'll make a blanket statement. You get into trouble when you generalize, but as I go to curling facilities, the one thing that I see with recreational curlers, generally they don't apply enough rotation. I I'm pleased to see, and it appears that way on uh Facebook when I see videos, that uh most curling facilities now have the equipment and the expertise to texture the rocks. And they do they do so at the beginning of the season, they'll probably do them again around uh Christmas break, maybe even a third time before the end of the season. So make sure that you have positive rotation. Uh minimum, absolute minimum from release to stop on a draw is three complete rotations. That's the bare minimum, and again, that's another generalization. The other aspect of rocks coming down the ice on at Sabon Foods Arena in Victoria is those rocks, again, for draws, they're not curling. Well, they are curling, but they're breaking. In other words, the trajectory of the rock, the path of the rock is not a uniform curve the way it is in most curling facilities. No, they're they go relatively straight, straight, straight, and then you just see them break. I'm sure the same impression that I had that uh they're trying to draw to the center line, perhaps you know, to the button, and as the rock approaches the top of the house, it's still like four feet from the center line. Well, it hasn't reached the break point yet. So you've got to be very careful about that, and they're very cognizant about the break point because you don't want to brush through the break point either, because it can really mess up the trajectory of a rock that way. So there's uh two aspects of delivering a curling rock. The last item on my clipboard is this new scoring system. Uh when I refer to scoring system, I mean scoring the performance of the curlers as they make curling shots. And I I really like this system, and it's in three parts, and we have to learn three new words here. The words are ace, field, and edge. Ace, field, and edge. So let's take them one at a time. This is my understanding from watching the games. The ace percentage is the number of shots that are fully made. Where under the old system, the old four-point system, the curler would have got a four, maybe even a five. That's sort of the traditional shooting statistic, and they call it ace. Then field is exactly that, and the field to which they referred were all of the shots that were played in last year's slams. Uh I third heard 31,000 shots, 34,000 shots. Well, the the field percentage is the scoring that would be made by all of the curlers playing all of that particular type of shot over the course of, as I said, a full slam season. Because it's important when you get to the edge, because that's the difference between you as an individual and that average of the field. And so if the field uh statistic was say, you know, 83% on that particular shot, and you shoot 85%, well, you got a plus two. If if the field uh on the shot was 83, but you only were scoring at 80, then you were minus three. And I like that scoring system. I thought it was really good. So again, ace, that's the shots that are fully made. Field, the average by all of the players who played that type of shot last year in the edge in the uh uh slam games, and edge is your performance compared to the field, either plus or minus. So I thought that was really good. Ace, field, and edge. I think we better get used to it. My note-taking took it up to the playoffs, and I wasn't going to add anything more to that. I thought that what I had seen was worthy of note. But my friend Joanne Courtney and her voice, along with uh Brian Gushu, were the voices that you heard uh across your television. She did her own wrap-up and uh she did a great job. And so I'm going to use that as my exit sound bite. So here's Joanne Courtney talking about the men's and women's finals of the co-op Grand Slam of Curling.
SPEAKER_00The champions have been crowned here at the 2026 co-op invitational. The first slam of the year is in the books. Let's get you up to speed on exactly what went down. We started off the day with the women's final. It was Team Anderson out of Canada taking on Team Kong out of Korea. Now, Team Kong without Kong because Bove Kong, the regular skip, won the mixed doubles national championship. She was focusing on mixed doubles. We'll go to the Worlds in January. So it's Kyonye Kim who was new to the team. She played third on Team King Kim with uh Unjung Kim, went to the 2018 Olympics, won a silver medal there. So she is now in the skipping role with the rest of Kim Kong, backing her up. The rest of this team. First year women's also young. What an accomplishment to make it to this final. Okay, the story of this final for me was experience winning. Um, Carrie Anderson and company, uh Kerry Anderson herself playing in the 17th final. And then she came out firing. It was tied. 2-2 after three ends of play, though, in the fourth end. Team Anderson um with a huge score of two. Carrie ended up playing an angle raise onto some rocks in the button to score that two points. They took a 4-2 lead there. Never really looked back. They score uh two in the sixth end. Oh, she made a great hit on her first. She sent two. Oh, Kim just overcurled on a freeze, and Carrie made a draw for two there. So this one was handshakes um after fairly simple eighth. And uh, huge congratulations to team Anderson carrying herself in that game game player. Um revealing it. In the men's draw, it was Team Young Schwaller out of Switzerland taking on Team Ramskale out of Norway. Ramsfield company playing in their first line final. And again, experience ended up leaving out here to Team Schwaller's goal for in the third end. Ramsfield is heavy on a draw. All kinds of pressure from this fourth and from Switzerland. Team Schwaller now remains at number one in the world. They widen their gap on the rest of the men's fields with that win at the first lap of the year.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Joanne. Well said and well recorded. And thank you for listening to today's episode of the Payne in the Class Podcast. Once again, this is Bill Sherart, Chartered Professional Coach, coming to you from Grand Bend, Ontario, Canada. Wherever you are, stay safe, my friends, and don't forget those wise words of that great North American philosopher Charlie Brown. Don't focus too much on things that make you sad because there are so many things that can make you happy. Until next time, you have to