A Pane in the Glass Podcast
This podcast is hosted by Bill Tschirhart, a chartered professional coach with Coaches of Canada. It's for coaches, instructors , athletes & parents at all levels of experience & skills. Using articles from Bill's coaching manual ("A Pane in the Glass: A Coach's Companion"), his blog site (truenorthbill.blogspot.com), his 30+ years coaching & instructing athletes, augmented by interviews with highly skilled & experienced experts, the aim of "A Pane In The Glass Podcast" to provide a valuable resource of information all the while producing episodes that will entertain the listener.
A Pane in the Glass Podcast
The Chair Of World Curling's Athlete Commission
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
As the title of this week's episode indicates, I chat with the newly appointed chair of World Curling's "Athlete Commission", Harri Lill from Estonia. We talk about the Athlete Commission plus curling in general. Harri welcomes anyone who wishes to contact the Athlete Commission (athlete.commission@worldcurling.org) to not hesitate to do so!
Welcome to another episode of a payment class podcast. This is your host Dr. Art coming to you once again from my home brand Ontario, Canada. I'm just going to kettle and start with first page. My guest today is Harry Lill. And those of you who are especially interested in the discipline of mixed doubles will know that Harry and his now former partner, Marie Caldvy, were truly one of the top mixed doubles teams in the curling world. And in 2024 were silver world mixed doubles champions. He is now the chair of the Athletes Commission for World Curling. And I must confess, during the interview, I kept using the word counsel when I should have said commission, so I'll fall on my sword and uh confess to that air. So my apologies. He is the chair of World Curling's Athletes Commission. And we, of course, talk about that. But before we got around to a discussion about his role as chair of the Athletes Commission, we talked about curling in general and mixed doubles in particular. So sit back and enjoy what you I hope you will find educational and informative. So please welcome back to the Microphone of the A podcast from Estonia, where it is sometime in mid-afternoon, but for me it's seven o'clock in the morning here on the Shore Way Hero. Harry Lil. Harry Lil, one of the very best mixed doubles curlers, and of course, mixed doubles, you're talking about a two-person uh discipline for the Olympic sport of curling. So uh Harry, give us a bit of a background as to how mixed doubles curling got started and where we find ourselves today.
SPEAKER_00Oh, what an introduction. Uh well, uh not sure if I'm uh if I'm one of the best, uh definitely one of the most experienced ones for sure. I've been uh around uh for a while in Mixed Doubles. Uh yeah, I think uh mixed double doubles as a discipline it's in a great place right now. Uh during the last few Olympic cycles, when it has been an Olympic uh discipline as well, it uh has gone through uh a great uh development, and uh I think uh actually the numbers from uh Milano Cortina show show it as well that uh it's found its place in the Olympic um Olympic Games and uh people are watching it and it's uh really thrilling. I think uh some people find it uh even uh uh more thrilling than the four-play person game, as it's uh just so fast.
SPEAKER_01Well, and by fast, I think you're referring to the pace of play. It's not so much the length of time that the game takes, and of course that is shorter than a four-person version, but it's the pace of play. There's not a lot of downtime, so to speak. For people who have not watched a lot of mixed doubles curling, take us through the a game as to just you know how it works and the number of rocks that you play and who plays which rocks of the of the group, and so give us a bit of an update there as well.
SPEAKER_00Mixed Doubles is basically a shorter version of the regular game where you already have two pre-placed rocks before you start to end. Uh you have two players, one male, one female, and uh one player chose rocks number one and five, and then the other player chose the middle rocks, two, three, and four. As you only have five rocks to throw and very limited uh thinking time, on average you have only 30 seconds uh for every shot to make your decision and deliver the rock, then uh you really have to be on your toes in terms of uh thinking quickly and executing uh quickly as well. So often you see sweep uh like players uh throwing their own rocks and then sweeping their own rocks and so on. And uh due to the fast pace of play, you also get a lot more mistakes. Uh uh and uh I think that's what's uh interesting about it as well. The rules by themselves they aren't that complicated, but uh but uh due to the pace of play, the mistakes that happen, they uh generate big ups and ups and downs in the games, which um gives you comeback opportunities as well.
SPEAKER_01Uh a recent development, um past few seasons, uh the power play. What what is that? How does that work?
SPEAKER_00Both teams have um have a chance in once in a game to use their power play. Uh this means that the stones will be placed uh to towards the side of the sheet instead of uh stones uh pre-placed rocks being in the middle of the sheet. Essentially what it does uh it generates more scoring opportunities for the teams with hammer as the middle of the sheet is empty, so for sure you can always score a point, or it's easier to do so at least. I think these days it's also used as a defensive tool. Often you can minimize the steal opportunity for for opponents and so on, because the middle of the sheet is empty, and for the opponents it's uh much more difficult to generate the steal out of a power play end.
SPEAKER_01You've said that uh one member of the team delivers rocks one and five, and the other uh two, three, four. The rules allow you to change during the game. I don't think that happens very often. Have you ever when you played with Marie? Did you ever change during a game?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um I think during 10 years, me and Marie played together. We've maybe changed once or so, but we've played uh I don't know, a couple of uh thousand games or so, maybe a little bit less, but uh definitely uh over a thousand games together. So uh yeah, not that often. I think uh at the at the top level, all Knicks doubles teams they pretty much already know which way they work uh the best together. And often teams might change when they play a power plant or something, or in specific, very specific scenarios, but 99% of them they they play in their uh designated lineup, let's say. Uh but there are some teams uh who have female uh throwing to middle stones. The most common version is to have a male throwing to middle rocks, but there's very successful teams of the opposite order as well. For example, uh the current uh national jamp uh champion from Japan, uh, they have a female throwing to middle rocks, and there's other examples as well. Yeah, different combinations can work.
SPEAKER_01That was going to be my next question because it did seem as though the male was playing uh two, three, four and the female was playing one and five. From a team dynamics perspective, and I'm I'm a big proponent of team dynamics, especially in the four-person game, because you've got four people, I think it's uh for aspiring uh competitive teams, it's something that's overlooked because uh if you if your team dynamics are not solid, you can distract one another. And so when you're working with just one other person, describe the team dynamics on a on a mixed doubles team.
SPEAKER_00I think even when it's a team of two, uh still the dynamics play a crucial role. Um, and I think uh especially if you look at the top teams, you also have uh uh some sort of a support team or coach and uh uh support staff with you as well. So in that sense, the dynamics with all these people I think uh plays a very important role. For the two people on the ice, for example, me and Marie, we put a lot of work uh with our sport psychologist into making sure that communication is uh the most effective and uh you know that the other person would uh get the same uh kind of message you would uh like to relay to him or her, right? So because very often in life we see situations where we say one thing, but the person we're talking to hears uh uh something totally uh different, right? Uh so I think in curling it's very important, uh whether it would be four-player or uh mixed doubles, uh, to make sure that you work on this communication part and uh you make sure that uh uh you know where the other person is coming from and you try to avoid assuming in general. So keep it very stupid simple and uh explain uh everything uh very thoroughly uh to make sure that uh your message uh gets across.
SPEAKER_01And when you alluded to pace of play, you have to be very efficient in the communication because you don't have a lot of time to get it wrong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. Um you have to be efficient, you have to well, it's uh probably good to know beforehand who will take the decision in which kind of uh situations. You know, often in game uh you might have different uh opinions in terms of what to play with your teammate. It's good to know who's going to make the decision when the when the opinions sort of are split. In general, uh we how to solve this different situations. But I I think uh playing and then uh analyzing the games you played, especially if you can listen to the audio, it helps a lot.
SPEAKER_01Well, certainly in Canada, uh mixed doubles every year there are more and more athletes who are moving to mixed doubles and if I can say focusing their season as a mixed doubles player. Uh how does a mixed doubles team practice?
SPEAKER_00I think in many ways it's the same as a four-player team practice. Uh depends, of course. If you live in the same area in Estonia, we're lucky because you know we only have one curling ring, so that means everybody pretty much uh practices in the same place. So uh we never had a situation where you uh you have to practice in different places, but uh I think throughout the years uh we worked from uh with different uh coaches from abroad, and uh you have learned so much over the years what kind of things to practice. Um you still uh focus on the same kind of skills to make shots, even though the game uh looks very much only around the center, then uh there might be a very crucial double or uh hit and roll or in-off you have to throw at a random end. So you have to be ready for those shots as well. So I think it's uh basically the similar kind of training, uh as as often uh as it often is, uh the more solid your technique is, the easier it is to make shots, and especially when you're uh under uh time pressure or uh exhausted.
SPEAKER_01Well, now you mentioned your curling facility. You and Marie graced the podcast uh a season or two ago, and you described your curling facility. Tell people what it is and how it started and what it was before it was a curling facility.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, our story is in that sense quite unique. That uh we well, we got to the Olympics last year, but uh we started our uh curling careers in an old Soviet missile factory. So uh yeah, I think there aren't too many stories coming from a missile factory to the Olympics, uh especially in the curling world. So uh so definitely quite unique. Uh we got our real curling rink, uh let's say 11, uh I think it's 11 seasons ago now. Uh so we have one uh free sheet there in Tallinn. We're lucky lucky in the sense that um uh there's quality ice there. Uh it's basically like uh more like a high performance center, not really like a curling club. It's uh attached to uh and a municipality ice rink, which has uh uh three other hockey pads. It's uh it's a good facility to practice it, that's for sure. And uh we're lucky to have different mixtables and men's and women's events uh uh hosted in Tallinn as well. So often the very best competition from the Walls uh come comes here to play, and uh many teams these days come to practice in Tallinn during summer and so on. So uh we're very lucky to have what we have, and hopefully there will be more rink rinks in uh in Estonia in the future.
SPEAKER_01I'm pretty sure you're the only country that started in a missile factory. So I think that record is gonna stand for quite some time. How many curlers are are in your country right now, approximately?
SPEAKER_00Um unfortunately, we only have like uh around 100 curlers. It sounds like a low number. It is a low number, but uh funnily enough, uh all the people who curl in Estonia they want to practice a lot. So to practice a lot, you need quite a lot of ice time as well. Uh of course, I think thanks to me and Marie playing at the Olympics, uh curling is uh now much more known for Estonian people, so it's easier to attract new club members, uh new people to play the game. And uh yeah, it's nice to see that uh we made a difference in that sense that uh uh there is more and more people coming in now.
SPEAKER_01No question, you and Marie put curling on the map in Estonia. I remember asking uh uh an athlete one time how many curlers were in that person's country, and they said, I not only can tell you how many there are, I can tell you who they are. So it's humble beginnings, but great. Okay, let's uh switch topics here. You are now the uh chair, president. What's the noun? What's the correct noun here of the Athletes Council for World Curling? So what is your position?
SPEAKER_00Uh I'm now the uh chair for the Athlete Commission for World Curling, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Tell us about it.
SPEAKER_00Uh well, I've actually been a member of the Athletes uh Commission uh for quite a while now. Uh before me, when I joined the commission, the chair was uh Jill Officer, which many people might know, and then uh Tyler George after that. So I'm uh following very uh let's say only people with gold medals in that uh in that sense. Uh the role of our athlete commission is to communicate the interests of the high performance curlers around the world and uh in in essence to be the collective voice of those curlers. Uh we do not represent only high performance curlers, we also try to look at the low lower levels and what kind of uh problems uh all curling athletes have. But when we have to make a choice, then um uh you know we have to keep the high performance players uh in mind first. And then we also look at wheelchair topics, uh, mixed doubles, all kinds of curling disciplines. So basically it's a totally separate uh body from the world curling board in that sense that it's uh it's uh neutral and it's uh not uh involved with world curling uh in any way besides uh uh being like it's uh not part of the governance structure, let's say. So Alfred Commission can uh make the decisions the way the way they want to and uh the way we we think is the best. And uh, I'm very happy to have a commission of uh ten people now who we have people from around the world and uh very experienced curling players uh who have been around for a while. So I think um we have a really good group of people who are willing to put their own time in to make the curling uh curling world better for all athletes.
SPEAKER_01I'm reminded of the line in the uh one of my favorite movies, The King's Speech. The line is you have a voice. And yeah and it's great that you have a voice because the term that I so frequently use is you are the customers. You're you're the reason why curling exists. Certainly governance, sponsors, all sorts of uh uh groups of people who have an interest in the sport. But uh, when it gets right down to it, it's the players, and you have to look after the players. When I say you, I'm referring to you know curling in general. Um how how often do you deal with issues that affect maybe uh curling in general? Not so much the high performance curlers, because most of the people that will hear our voice today are recreational curlers. Uh so if a recreational curler felt strongly about the way the game is going, what what might they come to you as a group and say, hey, we would like this particular issue to be presented? So in the past, what has come up that would have affected curlers across the world, not just high performance?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, very good question because a lot of the work that the Afflet Commission does, it's uh it's never uh never uh seen uh from the public eye, actually. So you you might need might see some end results, but uh actually there's a lot of work going on on the background that uh uh always Afflet Commission um can always be contacted by an email, afflet.commission at workcarening.org. So basically anyone can write to us in that sense, and uh we deal with every letter that comes in. Doesn't really matter which level the athletes uh play at. In that sense, during last year, last year's uh I think the most hot topics, it doesn't matter which level we talk about, have always been the brooms, the sweeping techniques, what's allowed, what's not allowed. So lots of uh work and testing uh was involved with that. Um athlete commission can only do its work uh thanks to the athlete support officer who is uh who is a staff of world curling. Uh his name is Rob Gordon. So Rob Gordon is actually doing a lot of work for keeping the different rankings updated for uh athletes and uh so on. So for Athlete Commission as well, Rob is a very important resource. Right now, what's on the table for us is also if we talk about C-level events, the pre-qualifiers for world curling, uh the lowest level events for uh any member association if they enter the men's or uh women's field, what kind of systems should be used in the future. And uh, you know, in general, I think most of the work is related to rules and competitions, but uh we deal with every every topic that comes into uh that is forwarded from the from the athletes, and I only encourage people to uh send us more info about what they would like to see changed because only then we can uh make it happen.
SPEAKER_01And of course, uh rules right now have come to the fore with world curling because uh there is a now uh global uh rule book. I I think for most of uh uh curlers across the world, they didn't never really thought about slight differences. But of course, something happened at the Olympics with uh my our friends Mark and Oscar. And an editorial comment on my part, uh I I saw so many people say, well, you know, even though it was a little unsavory the way it was handled, I'll just use that word. But it's good for curling because now people are uh aware of the the Olympic sport of curling. I disagreed with that. Uh I I didn't like that it if if something was going to happen in our sport to make it more popular, I wish it would have been something positive rather than negative. So that's just an aside on my part. The the whole thing about you know the double touch, I kind of rolled my eyes, and I think most curlers uh who play this sport thing, you you really you really think that a finger grazing the back of the rock as it leaves your hand is gonna make a difference? Well, I've got breaking news for you. It probably doesn't, but of course it had to be dealt with. But that being said, okay, are there any rules that uh govern the sport in general, uh your discipline in particular, that uh need to be addressed?
SPEAKER_00I think uh there's always things you need to address, but uh if you would know uh what the things always are beforehand, uh you would be the smartest per person in the world, right? So uh yeah, it's uh always difficult to be a little bit uh ahead of the curve. I think uh brooms will be always uh always be an ongoing topic to make sure the game isn't too perfect, but at the same time it would uh benefit the best sweepers and so on. Um then uh yeah, uh four-player rule is now a requirement, but uh at the world curling tour ranking system events, uh you are still allowed to play with three. So you don't have to play at with four players at all events because it's just not realistic to travel with five at to every tour event. So there is uh slight leeway still there. Yeah, I think uh timing rules are topic. I think in general, we as a sport, we have to make sure how to keep the product we have still relevant. So IOC as well, after every Olympics, International Olympics Committee, they measure our sports against every other winter and summer summer sports. So we have to make sure that our sports stays uh relevant, that people watch it, and not only the true hardcore curling fans, but uh people around the world watch it and uh they would see it as something exciting to follow. So so I think that's the hardest part of uh making sure the rules, uh rules are the best, uh not only for the athletes, but also for the product in general.
SPEAKER_01So back to the four-person uh stipulation, if I can call it that, that's that only applies to Olympics? Do do I have that right?
SPEAKER_00Uh basically the four-placer uh four-person rules applies to major events. So world curling events, uh national championships, uh things like that. But if you play um a tour event somewhere with your team, then you're not you don't have to have uh four players uh per se. So uh on world curling website uh there's a specific description about that. Uh but basically the organizers have a choice to uh choose whether they would like to implement the rule or not. Uh but if the uh event gives world curling two ranking points, then there has to be an ability to play with three free players. Just to make it uh still reasonable for athletes to travel with uh four players. So that's the that's the reasoning from Athletes Commission side behind it.
SPEAKER_01Well, this is the start of the uh the new quadrennial first day with the new teeth here, it seems. And we've never thought about curling in terms of blocks of four years. Um I remember a friend of mine uh who was very instrumental in actually getting curling into the family of Olympic sports after it was adopted, said to me, Well, Bill, I'm a little bit concerned, and I thought I thought, oh, it's great. I mean, we're in the Olympics uh right now. And uh this person said, I'm a little concerned that the Olympic tail is gonna wag the curling dog. And I didn't know what my friend meant until the incident that happened with Mark and Oscar. I'm sorry to go back to this. But if that had happened in any other environment, it would have been a total non-issue. I think my my friend meant that the Olympic prize has a tendency to be almost too important, too valuable, and it may result in some things that maybe we you know we we didn't want. So I'll just ask, not in your position as chair of the of the athletes council, but uh what's your response to that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, it's difficult. Uh as an athlete commission uh chair, I'm also now sitting on the world curling board, but I'll give you my personal uh personal opinion. I think uh I'm in a different uh spot in that sense that I haven't seen the curling world without being part of the Olympics. So when I started curling, then it was already part of the Olympics uh uh program. But during the time I've been involved with curling uh last 22, 23 years, something like that, um I've seen a very big development curve in the curling world in general. And I think something which only happened or at least happened uh at the speed it happened, thanks to the uh sport being part of the Olympics program. The number of different drinks we have around the world, uh the number of countries really putting their high performance um sports budgets into curling and things like that. You know, it's difficult to imagine this happening without uh being part of the Olympics. So I think it's uh difficult to overestimate the influence of that. Um yeah, I think uh curling has changed a lot. I think uh maybe 30 years ago we could only see curlers as one uh one unit. I think uh the demands that the sports uh now put on the top-level athletes uh it's uh it's very high demands. It's like in any other sport. So I start to see curling more and more as uh something which has uh curlers as one big community, but then uh part of this uh curling community is also top-level athletes. And you know, we count curlers around the world everywhere in every country, but uh we rarely have uh special numbers for how many athletes you have and how many just curlers you have, right? So I think uh the sport is uh getting more and more professionalized, but I don't think it's taking much away from the lower level. I think eventually the success of the curling at the top levels also helps to have more and more rinse. Uh it helps to keep the rings running, uh stay the sport relevant. And uh I think we all want to have uh more younger and younger curlers uh come into our sport as well. And uh I think only being part of the Olympics uh that uh helps us do that.
SPEAKER_01So often at the Olympic Games, the Winter Olympic Games obviously, that the hottest ticket in town isn't necessarily the hockey and the skating. It's the curling. The fans that perhaps don't know quite so much about the game, if they can get a ticket to curling, it's really been very attractive. They they see it now now. Maybe they're not quite so attuned to being uh quiet when it should be quiet and boisterous when that's okay. But that's fine. Uh the the enthusiasm of the people who are sitting in the stands to see curling at the Olympics is that's all that the ILC, I think, really needs to see because it's extremely popular. And of course, media loves curling because it's a relatively small surface to cover from a television perspective. The sight lines never change, the pace of play allows for great commentary. So I think curling is in a great spot. And I now that you're uh part and parcel of the World Curling Council, I think that you'll be you'll get a really you know sense of that globally.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and uh let's be honest, curling used to be like a novelty being uh at first when it was part of the Winter Olympics. Uh but now as the sport has gone uh more professional and uh level has risen and uh and people have it's been part of the Olympic program for long enough, and also Paralympic program, then uh you know it's uh not a novelty anymore. It's uh something which uh people already expect when Winter Olympics are coming up. And I think uh it's especially important that we have two uh three different uh disciplines at the Olympics and uh as well as uh two disciplines at the Paralympics. So it's uh it's uh very important that we're visible there.
SPEAKER_01You you mentioned something I I I don't know if you caught me smiling, but when you said, well, I've I've never known the Olympics to not be an Olympic sport. We're we're we're not exactly in the same demographic group, Harry. For most of my career, curling was not part of the Olympics, but uh I think we we always wished it was. So well, thank you for doing this. Uh it's uh it's great. I think the uh the council has made a great choice. You're you're going to be very impactful in that group. And uh uh you're welcome back to the podcast at any time to let us know how it's going.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Bill. Thanks for the opportunity. And uh everybody make sure you uh write to the athletes.commission at world curling.org with any any questions you have.
SPEAKER_01I think you will agree with me that uh world curling's uh choice of Harry as the chair of the Athletics Commission was a white disponible. Mixed Doubles is a not just a discipline of curling, it has become an extremely popular discipline and talked about Facebook Play and all the reasons why mixed doubles has really captured the imagination of many curling fans, literally across the world. And again, if you are interested in contacting Harry and the Athletes Commission, the email address is athletes.com at worldcurling all1 word.org. So once again, athletes.commission at worldcurling.org. And if you do, please type ibeary on my behalf. So once again, thank you for joining me and don't forget that great North American philosopher Charlie Brown. Don't focus so much on things that make you sad because there are so many things that can make you happy. Until next time.